LJ Idol - Season 20 - Week 4: Sin Eater
Nov. 2nd, 2026 05:21 pm"Send an email to Da'Neen about that account," my coworkers would say or "You can drop your P.O. in Da'Neen's box," and I would search the employee directory and think "Do they mean Jean? Janine?" because in a library with 25 staff, those ladies worked here too. I finally had to ask my supervisor who looked completely confused as to why I was confused by the "Deanne is Da'Neen" business. I found out later that, when she was a little girl, her younger brother couldn't say her name so he called her that and it stuck for her whole life.
Da'Neen was, if you've heard the expression, whiskey in a teacup. A pillowy woman, full of laughter, she was partial to stretchy pants and billowy tunic tops in wild patterns. Most days she wore big curls piled high on her head in a messy bun and spoke in a gentle drawl that belied her interior steel. She was a great grandmother at 60, having had her babies young and then they had their babies young and so on as is often the case down here.
She told me her husband thought, when their children graduated from high school and moved out, he'd finally get her all to himself, but, with a twinkle in her eye she said "I didn't want to be alone with that old goat, so, I built a pool in the backyard and he's never had a moment's peace." Over the years we worked together, one of her grown kids or grandkids or both was always moving in and out of her house, someone getting divorced, someone not speaking to their mama. She embraced the phrase "If you don't have anything nice to say, come sit next to me," and was the best ear to gossip with on a slow Friday afternoon.
I'm pretty independent. Gen X latchkey kids usually are. Throw in a little emotional abuse and religious trauma and hell, I'm a walking, talking Swiss army knife who can do everything for myself from replace a toilet flange or a tire swing to bake bread and build a shed. I'm not great at asking for help. Da'Neen wasn't great at indifference though and she had a way of gently bulldozing you into opening up to her. She was everyone's mother if you needed a shoulder to cry on.
She was deeply Southern Baptist. Her cube in the Cataloging Office had printed Bible verses and Kirkland crosses on the wall. Her father was one of our towns COVID victims and losing him during the pandemic flattened her for a year. She'd sometimes reference her "Sweet Daddy in Heaven" and I wasn't sure if she meant God or her real father. But she spoke of him with such reverence and certainty I could almost believe he was peering down over a cloud as she spoke.
I was raised Catholic and, even though I haven't been in a Catholic church in years, it's near impossible to break free. They says it's like alcoholism - you're never full recovered. Shame and guilt, man, they make for a spiky childhood. I was eight years old when I went for my first confession, a rite of passage for little Catholic kids. I stood in a long line in the sanctuary at church with a bunch of other elementary schoolers in my frilly white dress, lacy socks and the most uncomfortable white patent shoes I've ever owned, waiting for my turn to see the priest.
Mary Powers, my mom's best friend, was our chaperone, because all the parents had to wait outside the sanctuary till we were done. The door to the priest's office opened, for this occasion the confession booth wasn't formal enough, and I walked in, wide-eyed at finally getting to speak to the priest in person. He was an ancient Irish man with a beautiful accent, his back rounded as though he'd spent so much tending his flock it had curved him like a shepherd's crook. He was a petite man with rosy cheeks and wispy-white hair. Our church was called St. Patrick's and for a long time I thought that's who he was, the saint made flesh, here to chase the snakes out of Georgia too!
My mother disciplined us with spankings and shame and I am not sure which stung worse but that day I was ready to unburden myself on the Lord. "Bless me father for I have sinned," I began and then reached into my cardigan pocket for my list of sins. My long list. At eight years old, I already believed I was perhaps the sinning-est sinner to have ever sinned and I wanted to make sure I spilled EVERYTHING. I was going home with my soul buttermilk-white and clean as a whistle.
The way Mary Powers told it, I was in that room three times longer than the other children, which embarrassed my mother to no end. The priest took my full confession with reverent dignity to my face, but Mary said afterwards he had to close the door for five minutes for laughing so hard. It was probably my story about blowing up frogs under the porch that pushed him over the edge. He told me to say three Hail Mary's and help my mother with the dishes and I would be made pure again. I was ecstatic.
Oh, the sins of an eight-year-old child compared to those of a twenty year old woman, a thirty year old woman. And now, forty-eight years of sin on my pockmarked soul. It's more holey than holy at this point. I don't think that priest would be laughing now. I doubt God forgives me with a few Hail Mary's either. I wouldn't even know where to begin.
On a quiet Saturday a few years agoI was working in my office selecting Easter titles for the Children's section because families love the holiday books, never you mind the post-Catholic turmoil I was pushing deeper and deeper into my gut as I added these innocent texts to my online cart. The Story of the Resurrection for Children (I know one naughty librarian that won't be going up to Heaven). Illustrated Easter Songs and Stories (I could sing 300 hymns a day and bathe in baking soda and not be clean enough to ever get Raptured.) It was right around here that Da'Neen came and dropped into a chair across from my desk.
"What are you doing here on a Saturday?" I queried.
"Ah, I had a doctor's appointment Wednesday so I'm making up some time. Just came downstairs to grab a little treat from the vending machine." She waved some Nutty Buddys at me. "Want one?"
"Uh, yes." I nodded emphatically and gave her the gimme gesture across my desk.
"What are you working on?" she asked."Keeping you in a job! Ordering some Easter books at the moment." I took a bite of the chocolate and wafer and sighed.
"And why do you look so sad about it?" she wondered, squinting at me sagely, a detective grabbing hold of a thread, about to unravel a whole damn tapestry.
I considered her face, open and curious. Confession is good for the soul I'd been taught. She was stretching out her hand to me and I wanted to place my burden in it. Wanted to detonate my transgressions with someone else and be gifted peace. Bless me Da'Neen for I have sinned. It has been too long since my last confession. But she didn't deserve all that. I owed her something. The woman gave me a Nutty Buddy after all.
"So, I was raised Catholic. I don't go to church anymore because I don't believe in Catholicism, and I think the world is full of Christian hate disguised as religion. But, I still believe in God. I was taught that, because of how I've lived my life, even if I confessed my sins and said the rosary a thousand times, there are things I have done that will keep me from ever going to Heaven and that sucks. So much for Easter."
She didn't hesitate. "That's not what I was taught. My God forgives people's sins, that's why he sent his son to die on the cross. You know the verse, girl, 'So that whoever shall believe in him will not perish but will have eternal life.' So, if you just believe in Jesus, that he's your savior, it don't matter what you did in this life. I'm no angel but I'm going to Heaven. You will meet the Lord in Heaven." She said it like a benediction, pointing her Nutty Buddy at me to bless my broken soul.
Well, what a fucking revelation! In that moment, in her unwavering faith, I could see the Pearly Gates opening before me where before they had been locked tight. The problem was, I don't know that I DID believe Jesus is my savior. There's just too many questions.
Like, why is a Catholic God such an unyielding sonofabitch? What's with all the rage and ego? That God sounds more like my father than a benevolent savior. Why would a Baptist God let any old asshole go to Heaven simply because they proclaimed to believe in Jesus Christ as their Lord and Savior? And, why did they stop making those brightly colored sugar eggs in clear plastic packages you used to get scads of on Easter egg hunts in the 80's? I freaking loved those things.
As the transcendent Billy Porter once said "Religion is man-made, spirituality is divine." I know there is something out there, believe there is something bigger than me and this instant and the mire of corporeal existence we frequently find ourselves in. There are moments where I am overwhelmed by that which is inexplicably sacred in the greatness of the universe. But is it God, a Christian God with a capital G? I don't think so.
So, I no longer grieve the vacancy of the Heaven I was sold in my youth. My past is the past and cannot be undone. I live my best life today, and do good today, and love deeply today because who knows if anything comes after. If there is some Great Spirit, surely in their benevolent largesse they find my skepticism amusing and my heart not lacking, much like Da'Neen, or Dolly or Fred Rogers. The best people love without ego and judgement, without conditions and critiques. They just share their damn Nutty Buddy with a smile.